For nearly three decades, Ian Bailey has existed in a space few others endure — publicly judged, repeatedly resurrected in headlines, yet never convicted of any crime under Irish law. As Christmas arrives once again, his name returns to the news cycle, framed as though guilt were settled fact. It is not. There has never been forensic evidence linking him to the murder of Sophie Toscan du Plantier, and the Director of Public Prosecutions repeatedly declined to bring charges due to insufficient evidence. Having met Ian Bailey personally, and having examined the legal realities of this case, I do not believe he committed this murder. At a time of year associated with humanity and reflection, it is worth asking how many times a man can be symbolically buried in print despite being found guilty of absolutely nothing.